It is with great excitement, and a little sadness, that I would like to announce that I am retiring from the baking business!

Pinch of Sugar will be closed at the end of the business day on Friday, April 21! I would like to thank all of our wonderful customers that have faithfully purchased from us, We will miss you!

I will still make the wedding cakes for all the brides that have booked with me. I have been contacting them, so if you have not heard from me, please email me at

Once again, Thank You for being so supportive!

Weddings and birthdays. Anniversaries and graduations. A single cupcake to sweeten up your morning. Fresh cookies for the classroom. We have all your most delectable moments covered. Since 2011, we have worked to become one of Evansville's most trusted shops for all your most important occasions and every rewarding dessert in between. 

We specialize in the extraordinary, creating unique and elaborate 3D designs. Along with our made to order signature cakes, we also have a delicious assortment of cupcakes, fresh cookies, and cake balls in stock to choose from everyday.   

All of our cakes are made to order, so give us a call or visit the shop today to make your next big event the most delicious one yet.